English
Deutsch English Français Italiano
  • FAQs
  • Knowledge base
    • BASICS OF COPYRIGHT
    • Where... is the work used and which national law is applicable?
    • What... is a protected work?
    • Who... owns the copyright in the work?
    • Which... rights in the work are protected?
    • How... may other people use a work?
    • And... responsibility and sanctions?
    • Copyright and social media
  • Training
    • Training Offer
    • Case Studies
  • Advising
  • About
    • CCdigitallaw
    • Affiliation
    • Events
  • News Archive

  1. English
  2. Copyright
  3. 5. HOW... may other people use a work?
  4. 5.6 The right of quotation
  • Basics of Copyright
  • 1. WHERE... is the work used and which national law is applicable?
  • 2. WHAT... is a protected work?
  • 3. WHO... owns the copyright in the work?
  • 4. WHICH... rights in the work are protected?
  • 5. HOW... may other people use a work?
    • 5.1 How does the law compensate the encroachment of the author's exclusive right?
    • 5.2 Private use
    • 5.3 Archive and backup copies
    • 5.4 The temporary copying of a work
    • 5.5 Restriction for scientific research
    • 5.6 The right of quotation
    • 5.7 Use of orphan works
    • 5.8 Use of works by people with disabilities
    • 5.9 Works on premises open to the public
    • 5.10 Collecting Societies
    • 5.11 Reporting current events
  • 5b. HOW ... can other people use a work? - Contractual licenses
  • 6. AND... responsibility and sanctions?
  • 7. Copyright and social media

5.6 The right of quotation

Index To Consider Good to know FAQ

Published works (text, image, sound, film, etc.) may be quoted by everyone pursuant to the limiting provision of Art. 25 para. 1 CopA; however, the quotation must serve as ‘an explanation, a reference or an illustration’ (documentary function of the quotation). A quotation which, for example, only serves as a decorative illustration is prohibited; one example is an image which has no relationship to the text.

Furthermore, the extent of the quotation must be justified by its purpose. This means you may only quote as much as is necessary from a work. However, in individual cases, this can also be an entire work, i.e. an entire poem when this is required for a textual analysis.

Quoting means that excerpts of a work protected by copyright are used word for word, true to life, note for note, etc. Conversely, this means that works that are no longer protected may be quoted without having to comply with Art. 25 CopA. The limitation of the exception of quotation (Art. 25 CopA) does not include paraphrasing. Paraphrasing is the corresponding basic adoption or summary of a (protected) text work. Unlike with quoting, you share the content in your own words when paraphrasing.

The quotation must be designated as such and the source from which the quote originates specified (Art. 25 para. 2 CopA). Furthermore, if the authorship is visible in the source, this must also be specified.

If a quotation is not disclosed as such, this is considered to be plagiarism, because the person doing the quoting is masquerading as the author of the passage or the image, etc. The author whose rights are thus infringed can take a stand against this pursuant to Art. 68 CopA.

To Consider

Obligation to quote, not only pursuant to the law

In the case of paraphrasing but also in the case of quotes from works that are no longer protected, it is considered good scientific practice to identify the paraphrasing or quotation and specify the source – in particular in teaching and research – otherwise, this is an example of scientific misconduct.

The right of quotation is a mandatory law

The right of quotation pursuant to Art. 25 CopA is a mandatory law (statutory licence). It cannot be excluded by a contract. However, there are problems in this respect in relation to works which are only offered in digital form, to which the users of the work only have access when they have paid a licence fee. In this way, perception of a work – the fundamental condition to be able to quote a work – is no longer guaranteed. Although these works are basically published, only those for which a licence fee is paid for access are made available and thus also quotable. If you do not pay a licence fee, you do not receive any access to these works and also cannot quote from them as a result; whereby the exception of quotation – the right to quote published works without consent of the author – will be in vain. (c.f. also Hilty, Urheberrecht, 2011, 205f in this regard.

Good to know

Plagiarism

Plagiarism describes the ‘unauthorised adoption of third-party spiritual products; the theft of intellectual property’ (Fröhlich Gerhard, Wie rein ist die Wissenschaft? - Fälschung und Plagiat im rauen Wissenschaftsalltag, in Etzlstofer Hannes/Katzinger Willibrand/Winkler Wolfgang, echt - falsch will die Welt betrogen sein, 2003, p. 82). On the one hand, plagiarism can represent an infringement of copyright if you do not identify a quotation as such (Art. 25 CopA). Because, in this case, the person who uses the quotation without specifying the source implies that the work comes from them. However, plagiarism also generally describes situations when someone creates a work on the basis of the ideas or contents of others without clearly disclosing this fact. Plagiarism, i.e., unethical authorship, is frowned upon in academia in particular.

This scientific misconduct (which entails far more than just plagiarism, c.f. in particular the link collection ‘scientific integrity’ in this regard), depending on the guidelines of the individual universities or the Swiss National Foundation, for example, can have serious consequences such as loss of titles, exclusion from courses of study, etc. There are numerous examples and opportunities to commit plagiarism (list in accordance with the essay of G. Fröhlich mentioned above and in accordance with Weber-Wulff Debora, Copy & Paste = Plagiat? in Gasteiner Martin/ Haber Peter (Eds.), Digitale Arbeitstechniken für die Geistes- und Kulturwissenschaften, 2010, pp. 111–122):

  • Total plagiarism or copy and paste in toto: in the process, you adopt the entire work of another author as your own without any creative performance of your own.
  • Translation plagiarism: here you take a third-party work as a template and translate this into another language without mentioning the author of the original work. In doing so, you create a derivative work (Art. 3 CopA).
  • Partial plagiarism: adopting parts of a work
  • Shake and paste: here you use, as in the case of partial plagiarism, only parts of another work and put these parts together again in a new way.
  • Clause patching: in this case, only parts of sentences are used and put together into completely new sentences.
  • Idea plagiarism: thereby only the idea of the other author is cribbed and passed on in other words (the general perception is that ideas are not usually protected by copyright. They should be protected only when they appear in a form that is perceptible to the senses (BGE 116 II 351, 354; critical: Handle Marco, Der urheberrechtliche Schutz der Idee, 2013 N 1349). This means that, in the event of idea plagiarism, authors may not be able to claim any legal protection under copyright law. However, in the academic field, you can invoke the infringement of good scientific practice.
  • Structure plagiarism: in the case of scientific works of central importance, only the structure of a work, for example the table of contents of a dissertation, is adopted.
  • ‘Byline plagiarism: the student writes a thesis and the professor who has only skimmed through the thesis briefly offers the student the “honour” of being mentioned alongside him, the professor, in the byline.’ (Weber-Wulff Debora, Fremde Federn Finden - eine E-learning Einheit, 2013)
  • Self-plagiarism: this exists, for example, when you publish your own text again, but under a new title, which implies that this text is being published for the first time.
  • Cryptoamnesia: in this case, this means that you believe that an idea or a statement, etc. is your own; however, you have forgotten that you have seen this template somewhere else.

There are not only numerous opportunities to commit plagiarism but also very different types of plagiarists. Pupils are not the only ones who have been copying from Wikipedia without citing the source for some time now. Everyone, from pupils to university students, to experts through to professors can commit plagiarism. A helpful tool to find out more about plagiarism and how you can detect it is: ‘Weber-Wulff Debora, Fremde Federn Finden - eine E-learning Einheit, 2013’.

 

Collection of links on academic integrity

Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft DFG, Sicherung guter wissenschaftlicher Praxis, Denkschrift, supplements the 2013 edition

Swiss National Science Foundation SNF, Wissenschaftliche Integrität

FAQ

5.5-1 May a person cite excerpts of film, music and images?

Yes, even if they have been the subject of controversy in the literature to date, images and work excerpts are now recognised. However, in the process, it is important that you also disclose images, films and music as quotations, and correctly specify the source (Art. 25 CopA).

5.5-2 May I use a quotation in a work that has been put online? For example, an image or a music excerpt on my homepage?

Yes, pursuant to the law, it is irrelevant in which medium (book, pictorial, homepage, app, film,…) a quotation is used. However, it is decisive that the quotation has an explanatory, informational or illustrative function, is covered in the scope of the purpose of the quote, is disclosed as a quote, and the source is specified (Art. 25 para. 2 CopA).

May I just select an image from Google for a PowerPoint presentation and insert it into my presentation without any further ado?

If the image is a copyright-protected work (and that is generally the case), then it may only be used with the consent of the author and the owner of rights. However, the image can be entered into the presentation as a ‘pictorial quotation’. Then it has to serve an explanatory, informational or illustrative function, be covered in the scope of the purpose of the quote, be disclosed as a quote and the source specified (Art. 25 para. 2 CopA).

5.5-4 May I quote an unpublished work?

No, only published works may be quoted. However, in individual cases, the justification of the protection of legitimate interests may exist so that the quotation of unpublished works can also be justified. For example, public interest in a dispute with historical facts is ranked more highly than the interest of the author not to publish his work. (c.f. BVerfG, decision dated 17.12.1999 - 1 BvR 1611/99 in ZUM 2000, 316 in this regard).

5.5-5 May I cite an extract from a scientific article in which I am the co-author without citing exact sources in a new article?

No, if the source is not given, this is considered to be (auto-)plagiarism. In accordance with good scientific practice, you are not permitted to copy from yourself without disclosing that you have done so.

Services

FAQ FAQs, developed from real cases, allow you to quickly find answers to everyday digital law questions.
Knowledge Base A detailed knowledge base provides you insights into various legal aspects, currently with a focus on copyright issues.
Training A vast choice of on- and offline trainings are available together with interactive case studies to work through.
Advising A team of legal experts with competences ranging from copyright to data protection and licensing agreements are available for your questions.

About


CCdigitallaw is a national Competence Center in Digital Law that supports Swiss Higher Education Institutions (students, academic and administrative staff) in dealing with legal questions related to the digitization process and the use of new media and technologies. To do so, the Center offers various services such as a detailed knowledge base, FAQs, a wide range of on- and offline training activities and an advising service.

Partners


CCdigitallaw has been created through a project funded by swissuniversities. The center is the result of a collaboration between the Università della Svizzera italiana (USI), University of Basel (UNIBAS), University of Neuchâtel (UNINE), University of Geneva (UNIGE), and the Conference of Swiss Libraries (CBU-KUB).

Contacts


The team of legal experts working for the Center will be more than happy to answer your questions personally, by e-mail, phone or chat.
  • e-mail: info@ccdigitallaw.ch
  • tel: +41586664930
Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License

 swissuniversities.png

Disclaimer
de gb fr it

Cookies

This platform uses cookies for sessions, user support, analytics and user feedback. The session and user support cookies are necessary and cannot be disabled but you can opt out of the analytics and user feedback.
Analytics
User feedback